Frequent questions about the survey questions in a Church Life Survey
NCLS Research measures church vitality in 9 core areas of church life. Over 30 years our study has identified 9 Core Qualities shown to be central to the life or a vital and healthy church. The blend of these qualities points to the unique character of each church, its areas of strength and its potential for growth.
Core Qualities Model: The Core Qualities model was developed from the 1991 National Church Life Survey (Kaldor et al, 1992) onwards and involve 20+ denominations. The responses were based on the perspectives of people in the pews. There have been various configurations but the same core concepts have remained. This is primarily large-scale quantitative research, with both strengths and limitations.
Church health through sustaining attendance: Healthy churches are also “sustainable” in terms of their attendance with an inflow of new people. Inflow is measured by young adult retention (teenagers and youth growing into adult attenders), newcomers, and attendance change.
In an historic ruling in 2014, the High Court of Australia upheld the right of a transgender person to be registered as neither a man nor a woman with the NSW Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages. Therefore, the Australian government gives respondents the option to indicate that they identify as “Other”, rather than male or female.
Since 1991, the National Church Life Survey has been “What is your gender?”. The wording of this question has not changed. However, in line with government standards, ‘Other’ has been added as another option.
Space constrains the possibilities for the number of countries that we can list on our survey forms. Some individual countries are listed, and some groupings of countries. We have determined the list based on previous results from the NCLS regarding which countries of birth are more common and which are less common. In many of our surveys, Ireland is combined with the UK. However Ireland and Northern Ireland are in a separate category from Great Britain in the Catholic-specific Attender Survey forms.
There is no easy separation between Christianity and social issues. Faith may provide a framework for morality and ethics. Church is a social setting that interfaces with the broader community. Engagement with social issues is not just a matter for individual Christians; churches as institutions are themselves active in a range of ways on issues such as marriage and the family, poverty, justice, creation care and so on. Moreover, a large majority of Australian church attenders agree that Christians and churches should be involved in public policy issues.
The NCLS is a survey of churches, church attenders and church leaders, and has been tracking attitudes and actions related to a wide range of social issues since 1991. Our church denominations are interested in the relationships between faith, church life and social issues, and it is also in the broader public interest to understand the role of churches in public life today.
The 2021 NCLS includes questions related to issues such as child sexual abuse, domestic violence, voting preferences, asylum seekers and same-sex marriage. The results on these questions help us to understand views within the churches around contemporary issues of importance for the churches and for public life.
Typically, we publish such results in fact sheets, which are publicly available for use by various interest groups. Sometimes, academics also make use of the data. All publication and release of results and datasets passes a stringent assessment process by the NCLS Research Subcommittee and NCLS Board.
One of primary research areas for the 2021 NCLS Leader Survey is the resilience and wellbeing of church leaders. People in Christian leadership can experience tremendous levels of personal satisfaction in their work, but they can also experience considerable stress. The NCLS helps us to understand factors that help individuals to thrive and guard against burnout, and to share this understanding with churches.
We also include a smaller number of questions about personal wellbeing and mental health in some Attender Sample Surveys. The relationship between religion and wellbeing is a growing area of interest for researchers from a number of different disciplines. Individual results are always fully confidential.
Some of the questions in a Church Life Survey may have been commissioned by church denominations and regions. These questions help a denominational group focus on areas of specific interest or relevance to their churches. Commissioning groups will be provided with aggregated results reports and, if they request it, de-identified datasets containing the responses.
Online surveys enable tailored displays so that respondents only see questions that are relevant to them, based on answers that they give in the survey. For example, if you don’t have any children, you do not need to see survey questions about “your children”. Our survey engine can hide or display questions based on such logic, but it is not able to update question numbers accordingly. So if questions are not displayed, you might notice that some question numbers are missing.
The NCLS covers a wide range of research agendas, including: leadership and organisational effectiveness in churches; intersections between church and community, spirituality and wellbeing; tracking who goes to church; as well as trends in attitude, opinion, cultural and generational issues and more. This is a lot of territory to cover in our surveys. Because hundreds of thousands of local church attenders participate in the NCLS, we are able to have a large number of survey variants and still achieve good sample sizes.
In contrast, we have far fewer church leaders (several thousand participate), which means it is not possible to have many survey variants if we are to achieve a satisfactory sample size. As a result, the Leader Survey needs to be much longer than the Attender Survey.
The NCLS covers a wide range of research agendas. It is simply not possible to cover all the agendas in only one variant of a survey. In 2021, we have two Leader Survey variants.
The Leader Survey is for anyone involved in ministry or pastoral leadership within a local church:
• The most senior leader at a local church (at minimum), e.g. senior minister, pastor, priest
• The person most involved with this local church (if in a team)
• Ministry/pastoral leaders who contribute significant time or who help to set directions – both staff and non-staff.